Explanation
Reading the question: we can see that this question looks
like a lot of work. First, it has given us a difficult-seeming puzzle: this
country is has a low cancer rate, for non-genetic reasons, but people who move
there have a higher cancer rate. Secondly, we have a "NOT" question. Questions
with "NOT," like those with "EXCEPT," tend to be labor intensive, since it's relatively
slow to go through four good explanations and one bad one. The key technique
here is to use a very basic filter. In
"NOT" and "EXCEPT" questions--and all questions that are involved--you're often
basic served by a basic filter.
Applying the filter: carefully asking this simple
question, we can judge that (D) is the least explanatory of the cancer rate and
is therefore the answer. In (D), even if the exact "factor" hasn't been
determined, it doesn't matter, because the people who move to Orctania "attempt to follow the practices of the
inhabitants." So, we don't know whether it's being pollution-free and
stress-free and drug free and so on, but the people are doing all of them, so (D) doesn't help to
clear up the mystery.Everything else is
a good explanation. Choices (B) and (E) both point out that moving to the
country does not automatically equate with enjoying the benefits of the
environment or with adopting the behaviors. (C) points out that the population
moving to the country might be doing so because they are unusually cancer-prone
to begin with, which would explain why they would have a higher rate of cancer
even after reaping benefits. Choice (A) points out the possibility that some
forms of cancer aren't helped by living in Orctania--those
kinds depend only on genes, and, critically, it's possible that the people who
move to the country have genes more prone to those forms of cancer, somewhat
like the case of (C).
Logical proof: finally, we can use a test of (D) that is
similar to the negation test: say that it has
been established which factor was responsible. That's not automatically an
explanation, because, for all we know, the people who move to Orctania are perfectly recreating/copying that factor.
Since the situation is unchanged given (D) or its negation, (D) is unimportant
to the situation. The correct answer is (D).
If you believe you have found an error in this question or explanation, please contact us and include the question title or URL in your message.