Explanation
We have a situation here that has a relatively simple
situation but a fairly large number of potential variables to work with - we
have the girls, boys, and total in one group, the same in the other group, and
the ratios. We are not keen on working with 6 or so variables, so we will try
to get away with doing this purely by analysis of cases. So we will skip
equation-writing and go straight to the statements, evaluating them separately
at first.
Statement (1) looks insufficient
because we want to know a ratio, and it's not giving ratio-type information,
but rather an absolute difference. We will try to generate multiple possible
cases. We start with 10 girls and 10 boys and assign them to Group B, since
that has the smaller G/B ratio. Then Group A would have to have 20 boys and 10
girls. That doesn't match Statement (1), because the difference in the totals
is only 10. To make the difference 30, we multiply all the numbers by 3.
Case I:
Group A: 60 girls, 30 boys, 90 total. G/B=2
Group B: 30 girls, 30 boys, 60 total. G/B= 1
This is a legal case. To generate another case, we'll
start with a different G/B ratio in Group B... Say 1/2 in Group B. Group B: 10
girls, 20 boys, 30 total, G/B=1/2. Then Group A would be 20 girls, 20 boys, 40
total, for a G/B=1. Again, we multiply all the numbers to get the right total
difference. Again we have a total difference of 10 and so need to multiply by 3
to fit Statement (1):
Case II:
Group A: 60 girls, 60 boys, 120 total. G/B=1
Group B: 30 girls, 60 boys, 90 total. G/B= 1/2
Now that we have achieved two cases--is the answer to the
question in each case the same or different? In Case I, the ratio of the totals
is 90/60 or 3/2. In Case II, it's 120/90 or 4/3. Therefore, we do not have sufficient
information to answer the question definitively. Statement (1) is insufficient.
Statement (2) gives information about the G/B ratio in
Group A. If the G/B ratio in Group A is 6/5, then the G/B ratio in Group B is
3/5, by the condition in the question. Coming up with cases for this statement
is somewhat faster. We can do a case in which there are 6 girls, 5 boys in A,
and 3 girls, 5 boys, in B. In another case, we can keep the ratios but double
both numbers in Group A only. Both cases fit all the information given to us,
but in the latter of the cases, the thing we are asked, the ratio of A total to the B total, has doubled. Therefore, we can't
answer the question definitively with this information, and Statement (2) is
insufficient.
Combining statements, we need to test cases that fit both
conditions. It's for this type of circumstance that you want to keep your notes
for each case organized and not erased, so that, if you have to combine
statements, you don't have to redo any work. We can work from one of our cases
from analyzing Statement (1) and say we have 60 girls in Group A; then we need
to have 50 boys to get the G/B ratio specified by Statement (2). The G/B ratio
in group B must be half, so we change those girls and boys to 30 and 50.
Luckily, the total difference of 30 has been preserved, so this is a valid
case:
Case III:
Group A: 60 girls, 50 boys, 110 total. G/B=6/5
Group B: 30 girls, 50 boys, 80 total. G/B= 3/5
In this case the ratio of the total in A to the total in B
is
. Can we generate another allowed case? If try to
get a different case but keep the ratio, say by dividing by a number or
multiplying by a number, that keeps the ratio but it messes the condition of
Statement (1). And changing in some other way will alter the ratio. Therefore
Case III is, in fact, the only possible case when the statements are combined.
We therefore can know the ratio of the totals definitively, and the statements
together are sufficient. The answer is (C).
If you also approached this question with analysis by
cases and ran into problems, here are a few questions to ask yourself. First,
were you writing down too much or too little? It can be easy to run into
problems if you write nothing down,
because there are a few things to keep track of and access later. Another
consideration is the manner of choosing cases. Whenever you are dealing with
ratios, you multiply or divide to maintain a ratio, and each act of doing so
will change the sums and differences
of the elements involved. Keeping that in mind will make the process of
constructing cases more fluid. Lastly, consider whether you can go faster
sometimes by going slower. For example, it's sensible that you might hit a
situation such as Case III and stop and have to think about it. It's perfectly
fine to spend 10 or 20 seconds in your final evaluation of Case III to
determine the answer and it will generally be faster than trying to scribble
down a bunch of further cases more quickly than you have time to digest them
and see the patterns.
Again, the correct answer is (C).
If you believe you have found an error in this question or explanation, please contact us and include the question title or URL in your message.