Three Robots Eject Water

Welcome! You are encouraged to register with the site and login (for free). When you register, you support the site and your question history is saved.

Three robots, Q, R, and L, which eject water independently and simultaneously, each at a characteristic, constant rate, can fill a pool in 10 minutes. How long does it take Robot Q, working alone at its constant rate, to fill that pool with water?

(1) Machines R and L can fill the pool in 20 minutes.

(2) Machines Q and L can fill the pool in 15 minutes.

Review: Three Robots Eject Water




Explanation

Three robots!? Ejecting water!? What madness is this?! It's just a rate question. The common and careful phrases here are "independently and simultaneously" and "at a characteristic, constant rate." They mean that each robot works at a rate defined by a fraction, and that the combined rate is nothing other than the sum of the individual rates. So the information in the question means we can write:



Each of the T's represents a time, and each fraction is a rate with the units, . For example, the right-most fraction says that the robots together fill 1 pool (the top of the fraction) in 10 minutes. The left-most fraction indicates that Robot Q, if working alone, would fill 1 pool (the top of the fraction) in minutes. And is what we are looking for, in fact. Let's move to the data statements, separately first.

Statement (1) tells us that . If we plug that into our original equation, we can solve for . Sufficient.

Statement (2) looks equivalent, possibly, but it isn't. Along the lines of Statement (1), it would allow us to solve for , but that's not what we are looking for and we don't know the value of . We have three variables and only two equations, so we can't solve completely. (We didn't solve completely in the first statement, because we didn't get the times for R and L individually; we just got the time for Q through fortuitous algebra.) Statement (2) is insufficient.

The correct answer is (A).


If you believe you have found an error in this question or explanation, please contact us and include the question title or URL in your message.