Consumer Confidence Index III

Welcome! You are encouraged to register with the site and login (for free). When you register, you support the site and your question history is saved.

     The stock market tends to move in response to the release of the U.S. consumer confidence index (CCI) each month, signaling that individuals make investment decisions on the basis of this information. Such a behavior is mostly irrational. The CCI is generally agreed to be a lagging indicator; by the time the CCI has been released, the stock market should have already reflected the latest adjustments to its prices based on consumer sentiment. Furthermore, the CCI, to the degree that it reflects on the stock market, reflects only on the stock market as a whole, not on individual stocks. The questions that make up the CCI, indeed, gauge individual levels of confidence about factors, such as employment rates, that should have little direct bearing on most individual stocks relative to other factors. To dampen the influence of the CCI on the stock market, the Conference Board, the nonprofit group that reveals the information each month, should adjust its timetable in order to publish the CCI outside of stock market hours. In that case, the impact of the CCI on stock market prices will be smoothed and is more likely to reflect individual investors' business estimates and not their animal whims.

The passage suggests which of the following about consumer sentiment about the stock market?

Review: Consumer Confidence Index III


Explanation

This question asks about consumer sentiment in the stock market, which is material to most of the passage, so we can examine the answer choices keeping in mind the author's main idea: namely, that individuals are irrational in their use of the CCI. These answer choices are all in the very rough area of that idea, though we know that only one will be supported by the passage. For example, "irrational in their use of the CCI" does not quite support that they "have unwarranted trust in the CB." The CB is not untrustworthy; people are using its report incorrectly. So (B) is out. Similarly, (A) describes in a fashion what the CCI reflects; but if investors were concerned with these factors, their use of the CCI would be rational. So (A) is out. (C) touches on the fact that the CCI does not reflect on individual stocks. But the fact that consumers pay attention to something that poorly reflects on individual stocks does not mean that they pay no attention to the (other) things that reflect accurately; they may also pay attention to those things. So (C) is unsupported. (D) and (E) are rather like sides of a coin; their substantial difference is only in whether consumers lag or move quickly in their use of stocks. Which is supported by the passage? We are told that the CCI is a "lagging indicator," but this does not mean the consumers themselves lag; it's a description of whether the CCI is an indicator of the past or the future. Do we have grounds to think the consumer sentiment moves swiftly? We do. We can infer from the author's suggestion that the release of the monthly report affects consumer sentiment within business hours; otherwise it would not have a "smoothing" effect to release the report outside of business hours.

The correct answer is (E).


If you believe you have found an error in this question or explanation, please contact us and include the question title or URL in your message.